Taha Utopia
Read Quran Hasanat Muhammad ﷺ Understand Quran Library Tafsir Hadith Q&A New Muslims Tutors Memberships AI Agent Club Blog About

The Treaty of Hudaybiyyah: Why It Was a Victory

By Taha Utopia · Published 2026-11-19

The Muslims had set out for Makkah to perform umrah. At Hudaybiyyah, they agreed to turn back and return the following year.

The Muslims had set out for Makkah to perform umrah. At Hudaybiyyah, they agreed to turn back and return the following year. On the way home, while the Companions were still deeply distressed, Allah revealed the opening verses of Surah Al-Fath. The first calls what Allah had granted His Messenger a clear triumph. Qur'an 48:1 · Sahih Muslim 1786a

Why call it a victory when the pilgrims were still on their way home without having reached the Kaaba? The treaty itself helps answer that question.

What happened at Hudaybiyyah?

In the sixth year after the Hijrah, the Prophet ﷺ and his Companions travelled toward Makkah for umrah. Quraysh blocked their entry. Suhayl ibn Amr came to negotiate, and the two sides agreed to a truce. The Muslims would return to Madinah that year and be allowed to come back for umrah the next year. Safiur Rahman al-Mubarakpuri's The Sealed Nectar puts the retreat and the truce side by side in its chapter on Hudaybiyyah. The pilgrims would leave that day, and the agreement called for a ten-year suspension of hostilities. Sahih al-Bukhari 2731 and 2732 · The Sealed Nectar

For the people signing the treaty, the cost was immediate. One term required the Muslims to return people who came to them from Quraysh, even if they had embraced Islam. While the agreement was being written, Suhayl's son Abu Jandal arrived in chains. Suhayl insisted that he be returned. The Prophet ﷺ pointed out that the agreement had yet to be written and asked Suhayl to let Abu Jandal stay. Suhayl refused. The hadith records Abu Jandal's appeal to the Muslims and the suffering he had already endured. Read that part of the narration slowly. It gives weight to the word truce. Sahih al-Bukhari 2731 and 2732

What did Umar ask the Prophet?

Umar asked about the promise that they would go to the Kaaba and circle it. The Prophet ﷺ asked him whether he had said it would happen that year. Umar answered that he had heard no such date. The Prophet then reassured him that he would go to the Kaaba and circle it. Later, in Surah Al-Fath, Allah affirms that His Messenger's vision would be fulfilled and that the believers would enter the Sacred Mosque safely, Allah willing. Sahih al-Bukhari 2731 and 2732 · Qur'an 48:27

Yellow dunes and blue-gray flats in an ASTER satellite image of the Empty Quarter

The Empty Quarter, shown here to illustrate the Arabian desert landscape. Image credit: NASA/METI/AIST/Japan Space Systems and the U.S./Japan ASTER Science Team. Image source.

Why was the treaty a victory?

Ibn Kathir explains that the truce gave people room to meet openly. During the respite, Muslims could speak about Islam with people they had been at odds with, and more people embraced it. That is one of the gains the commentary draws from the opening of Surah Al-Fath. A safe visit to the Sacred Mosque still lay ahead, and the truce had already changed what was possible between the two sides. Ibn Kathir on Qur'an 48:1 to 48:3

Anas ibn Malik remembers how distressed the Companions were on the return journey. He also remembers how dear the revelation was to the Prophet ﷺ when it came. It is easy to judge the whole of a decision by the first thing it costs us. At Hudaybiyyah, the loss of that year's umrah was real. So was what the peace made possible. Sahih Muslim 1786a

There is a simple way to study this episode. Read 48:1 and 48:27 together, then read the negotiations in Bukhari. Ask what the Companions had hoped to do that day, what the treaty allowed them to do later, and what they could do as soon as the fighting stopped. If you want to see how a commentary connects the story to the verses, Taha Utopia's guide to reading tafsir online can help.

Sources and further reading

  • The Qur'an, Surah Al-Fath, 48:1 and 48:27. Word-by-word references from the Quranic Arabic Corpus for 48:1 and 48:27.
  • Sahih al-Bukhari 2731 and 2732, on the negotiations, Abu Jandal and Umar's questions.
  • Sahih Muslim 1786a, on the return journey and the revelation of Surah Al-Fath.
  • Ibn Kathir (abridged), commentary on Al-Fath 48:1 to 48:3, on the context and effects of the truce.
  • Secondary Seerah reading: Safiur Rahman al-Mubarakpuri, The Sealed Nectar (Ar-Raheeq Al-Makhtum), the English edition's Hudaybiyyah chapter.
  • Cover photograph: Rub al Khali 002.JPG by Nepenthes, CC BY-SA 3.0, supplied unedited. It depicts dunes near Liwa Oasis.

Related reading

  • Quran tafsir online: Free commentaries including Ibn Kathir and Maariful Quran.
  • Hadith collections online: Sahih Bukhari, Sahih Muslim, and the six books.
  • Understand Quran and Reflect: An interactive course that teaches the Arabic of the Qur'an through the Qur'an itself, so you can feel its meaning and connect with Allah.

Continue learning: Islamic Blog Index · Quran Tafsir · Hadith Collections · Ask a Question

© Taha Utopia. Dedicated to free Islamic education.

Privacy Policy Terms of Service Contact Us About Us Support Taha Utopia AI Agent Club